'Why Stop at AI Use? We Could Have Mandatory Disclosures for What Shampoo Brand the Developer Uses' — Epic Boss Tim Sweeney Says Steam Should Ditch Its AI Generated Content Disclosure

‘Why Stop at AI Use? We Could Have Mandatory Disclosures for What Shampoo Brand the Developer Uses’ — Epic Boss Tim Sweeney Says Steam Should Ditch Its AI Generated Content Disclosure

As the debate around the use of generative AI to build video games rages on, Tim Sweeney, boss of Fortnite developer Epic Games, has waded in to call on Valve to ditch its AI Generated Content Disclosure for Steam games.

Valve’s rules mean developers must disclose their use of AI-generated content on a game’s Steam store page. For example, the Steam page for Embark Studios’ Arc Raiders includes a note from the developer on how the game uses AI-generated content: “during the development process, we may use procedural- and AI-based tools to assist with content creation. In all such cases, the final product reflects the creativity and expression of our own development team.”

Activision’s Call of Duty also includes an AI disclosure: “our team uses generative AI tools to help develop some in game assets.”

null
Tim Sweeney says Steam should ditch AI disclosures. Photo by SeongJoon Cho/Bloomberg.

Sweeney, though, believes there’s no point in having such disclosures because pretty much all video games will use AI. Responding to one X / Twitter user who called on Steam and all digital marketplaces to drop the “Made with AI” label because “it doesn’t matter any more,” Sweeney agreed, adding: “the AI tag is relevant to art exhibits for authorship disclosure, and to digital content licensing marketplaces where buyers need to understand the rights situation. It makes no sense for game stores, where AI will be involved in nearly all future production.”

Sweeney’s tweet has sparked much debate about the rights and wrongs of Steam’s policy here. While Sweeney may be right to say the use of generative AI during video game development is becoming more prevalent, some say removing AI disclosures would make it harder for some customers to make informed purchasing decisions.

Activision was dragged into this debate recently when Call of Duty: Black Ops 7 players complained about AI-generated images they had found across the game, primarily focusing on calling card images with a Studio Ghibli-esque styling, following a trend of AI-Ghibli images from earlier this year. A member of U.S. Congress subsequently called Activision out, demanding tighter regulation to “prevent companies from using AI to eliminate jobs.”

In the case of art — particularly art sold in premium bundles or battle passes — it seems reasonable to expect a generative AI disclosure to help inform customers about their purchasing decisions. But this is not backed up by law, and Valve is enforcing this policy because it believes it is the right thing to do. And it’s worth point out that using generative AI to make in-game art and selling it to gamers is of course different to the use of AI in, say, NPC behavior or animation work — something that has been a part of video game development for years.

The ever chatty Tim Sweeney then used shampoo to reinforce his point in a response to another tweet — although, as many have pointed out, letting customers know about shampoo isn’t quite the same thing as, say, letting them know they’ve replaced artists with AI-generated slop trained on their work.

It’s no surprise to see Sweeney take this position on AI, given Fortnite’s extensive use of the technology. Over the summer, Epic released AI Darth Vader into Fortnite and announced plans to let people create their own AI NPCs. The original Darth Vader was voiced by James Earl Jones, who died in September 2024 at the age of 93. The AI version of his voice, powered by Google’s Gemini 2.0 Flash model and ElevenLabs’ Flash v2.5, was used with the Jones family’s permission. Within an hour of the feature going live, Fortnite players manipulated Vader into saying the kind of things very much associated with the Dark Side of the Force, including swearing. Epic soon patched it out.

Speaking to IGN in June, Sweeney predicted that small teams would soon be able to use AI prompts to make video games on the scale of Nintendo masterpiece The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild. “AI characters giving you the possibility of infinite dialogue with a really simple setup for creators means small teams will be able to create games with immense amounts of characters and immense and interactive worlds,” he said. “What would it take for a 10-person team to build a game like Zelda Breath of the Wild in which the AI is just doing all the dialogue and you’re just writing some character synopsis? That’s totally going to be within reach over the next few years.”

If you’re hunting for the best offers this week, we’re actively rounding up the strongest Black Friday deals on video games, tech, and more. You can find all our top picks and price drops in our full Black Friday hub, or check out our relevant pages for PlayStation, Nintendo, and Xbox deals.

Wesley is Director, News at IGN. Find him on Twitter at @wyp100. You can reach Wesley at wesley_yinpoole@ign.com or confidentially at wyp100@proton.me.



Source link

Read More
Developer of New Postal Game Shuts Down Studio After Game Was Announced, Then Canceled Over Gen AI Allegations
Developer of New Postal Game Shuts Down Studio After Game Was Announced, Then Canceled Over Gen AI Allegations
Sword of Convallaria X The Witcher 3: A Commemorative Interview
Sword of Convallaria X The Witcher 3: A Commemorative Interview
Gone Home studio is taking a soothing dip with lost souls in its newly unveiled lo-fi narrative adventure Springs, Eternal
Gone Home studio is taking a soothing dip with lost souls in its newly unveiled lo-fi narrative adventure Springs, Eternal
GTA Online Update Reveals First Look at Michael in the Grand Theft Auto Universe Since GTA 5 Launched Back in 2013 — and Settles Any Lingering Canon Ending Questions
GTA Online Update Reveals First Look at Michael in the Grand Theft Auto Universe Since GTA 5 Launched Back in 2013 — and Settles Any Lingering Canon Ending Questions
Bethesda boss and RPG lover Todd Howard names his 2025 Game of the Year, and it shouldn't come as a big surprise
Bethesda boss and RPG lover Todd Howard names his 2025 Game of the Year, and it shouldn't come as a big surprise
'Don't Bother Guessing. You're Not Going to Guess Right' — Tim Cain, One of the Creators of the Original Fallout, Has Rejoined Xbox Studio Obsidian to Work on a Mystery Project
'Don't Bother Guessing. You're Not Going to Guess Right' — Tim Cain, One of the Creators of the Original Fallout, Has Rejoined Xbox Studio Obsidian to Work on a Mystery Project
Fallout and Elder Scrolls boss Todd Howard defends AI in game development, but aims to "protect artistry" and "human intention" in his games
Fallout and Elder Scrolls boss Todd Howard defends AI in game development, but aims to "protect artistry" and "human intention" in his games
An Elder Scrolls TV series "can't be ruled out", Todd Howard teases, but remains tight-lipped on the status of the Wolfenstein adaptation
An Elder Scrolls TV series "can't be ruled out", Todd Howard teases, but remains tight-lipped on the status of the Wolfenstein adaptation
What to Expect From The Game Awards 2025
What to Expect From The Game Awards 2025
"I would appreciate it if you could pick it up again" Capcom schedules new Monster Hunter Wilds presentation as its director begs players to return to the game
"I would appreciate it if you could pick it up again" Capcom schedules new Monster Hunter Wilds presentation as its director begs players to return to the game

Related Post

"Has caused extreme damage to our brand and our company reputation" - Running with Scissors cancels Postal: Bullet Paradise over AI-generated assets... two days after reveal
"It's totally nonsensical!" Final Fantasy 14 composer's dream comes true, as game gets collaboration with Rage Against The Machine's Tom Morello
Sony London's cancelled fantasy multiplayer seemingly gets new lease of life in Cast Outs
Netflix acquires Warner Bros. in $82.7bn deal, including studios behind Mortal Kombat and Hogwarts Legacy
Real or AI fake? Suspicious off-screen Shenmue 4 trailer sparks excited debate